Judges in this round read all four novels in their assigned group, then rank those titles.
Group A
The Marriage Portrait — Maggie O'Farrell Now Is Not the Time to Panic — Kevin Wilson The Covenant of Water — Abraham Verghese Such Sharp Teeth — Rachel Harrison
Group B
The Whalebone Theatre — Joanna Quinn Joan: A Novel of Joan of Arc — Katherine L. Chen Our Missing Hearts — Celeste Ng Beyond That, The Sea — Laura Spence-Ash
Group C
Babel: An Arcane History — R. F. Kuang Stone Blind — Natalie Haynes Saturday Night at the Lakeside Supper Club — J. Ryan Stradal The Last Animal — Ramona Ausubel
Group D
The Great Reclamation — Rachel Heng VenCo — Cherie Dimaline Yellowface — R. F. Kuang Loot — Tania James
Group E
Symphony of Secrets — Brendan Slocumb Ghost Girl, Banana — Wiz Wharton The Bandit Queens — Parini Shroff My Murder — Katie Williams
Group F
Birnam Wood — Eleanor Catton I Have Some Questions for You — Rebecca Makkai People Person — Candice Carty-Williams Lone Women — Victor LaValle
Group G
Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow — Gabrielle Zevin The Force of Such Beauty — Barbara Bourland Small Mercies — Dennis Lehane Better the Blood — Michael Bennett
Group H
Hello Beautiful — Ann Napolitano Biography of X — Catherine Lacey The Daughter of Doctor Moreau — Silvia Moreno-Garcia Romantic Comedy — Curtis Sittenfeld