Judges in this round read all four novels in their assigned group, then rank those titles.
Group A
The Cold Millions — Jess Walter The Death of Vivek Oji — Akwaeke Emezi A Burning — Megha Majumdar The Midnight Library — Matt Haig
Group B
Mexican Gothic — Silvia Moreno-Garcia Hamnet — Maggie O'Farrell The Prophets — Robert Jones, Jr. The Five Wounds — Kirstin Valdez Quade
Group C
Everyone Knows Your Mother Is a Witch — Rivka Galchen Crooked Hallelujah — Kelli Jo Ford Gold Diggers — Sanjena Sathian Whereabouts — Jhumpa Lahiri
Group D
Homeland Elegies — Ayad Akhtar The Vanishing Half — Brit Bennett Great Circle — Maggie Shipstead Transcendent Kingdom — Yaa Gyasi
Group E
How Beautiful We Were — Imbolo Mbue Piranesi — Susanna Clarke Project Hail Mary — Andy Weir Of Women and Salt — Gabriela Garcia
Group F
The Atmospherians — Alex McElroy Leave the World Behind — Rumaan Alam My Year Abroad — Chang-Rae Lee Sisters — Daisy Johnson
Group G
The Rib King — Ladee Hubbard Phase Six — Jim Shepard The Pull of the Stars — Emma Donoghue Malibu Rising — Taylor Jenkins Reid
Group H
The Other Black Girl — Zakiy Dalila Harris Hour of the Witch — Chris Bohjalian Peaches — Helen Oyeyemi The Invisible Life of Addie LaRue — V. E. Schwab